"Paintings With Personality"

7 Reasons Why Oil Paintings Are Preferred Over Watercolors

This man was in a restaurant in Columbia, CA. He was sitting at a table with friends, each one of them more sketchable than the other. I used non-permanent ink and applied water to it later.

I’m dealing with a lousy cold, and feel like a toad. I promise that tidbit is the last of my prose for today. My vocabulary seems to have been reduced to moaning and groaning so, I will keep this post short and sweet. Otherwise, you might hear me moan in print.

I recently read in “The Art of Watercolor” an article about Naomi Tydeman, and written by Laurent Benoist. Naoim said, “It’s a strange thing that watercolour (I use the British spelling) has always had a lesser value than oils despite the fact that we’ve been using it for 40,000 years. The RI (Royal Institute), has referred to it as merely ‘drawing’ and dismissed it as a valid art form.” She continues “Yet everyone knows it is more difficult and requires so much more dedication and talent. Schools rarely teach it, art colleges rarely refer to it and yet every single little community art society uses it. People retire and take up watercolours. They take them on holiday. They travel with them. They are so very popular and yet still snubbed by the Establishment.”

After the 40,000 years, mentioned above, I think watercolor is here to stay, but can’t figure out why it doesn’t get the recognition of an oil painting.  It seems that something that old would be mentioned in art history books, but it isn’t. I have been thinking about the subject for quite a while. A friend and I were discussing it just the other day.

I’m sure there are more than a few answers to the conundrum, I have been able to come up with seven, maybe you can think of others.

  1. In spite of it being more difficult than painting with oils, many people think of watercolor as a medium for hobby painters or Victorian ladies.
  2. For years, many artists used watercolor as thumbnails for their oil paintings. As a result, it is considered a medium used for more insignificant art.
  3. Art museums don’t often display watercolor, because it is light-sensitive and care must be taken to exhibit them without damaging the colors. The Metropolitan in New York keeps their Sargent watercolors in a dark case on one of the mezzanines.
  4. Watercolor is identified with things other than fine art, such as children’s books, bird identification books, and various manuals.
  5. Owners can get up close and personal with their oil paintings, even touch them if they want. Not so with watercolors which need to be protected under glass.
  6. Watercolor is done on paper which can be damaged. Oil painters use longer lasting and expensive surfaces.
  7. Water based paints, like watercolor, can be manipulated after they are dry. Although, there are mediums that can be applied to watercolor paintings that protects them without glass. Oil paintings don’t have to be under glass at all.

From the list above you would think I don’t like watercolor, but I love it. In fact, watercolor is my primary medium. It seems that all art, no matter what medium should be accepted equally. Hmmmm, is that prejudice? What do you think?  Later, Judy

http://judyballance.com/

 

Watercolor is a medium that can be as demanding and temperamental as those who choose to paint with it. But it is a colorful and exciting medium all the same – well suited to describing the many moods of the subject, as well as those of the artist wielding the brush. (Jean Burman)

 

The Nicest Way to View Art

Comments

3 Responses to 7 Reasons Why Oil Paintings Are Preferred Over Watercolors

Hi Judy, hope you are feeling better.
Wc vs oil, agree with all your points and add some prefer oils for surface texture, not flat like wc
Certainly glare can be an issue especially for decorators.
I' m sure there are others our oil painting buddies can come up with. Like the sensuality of the paint texture-butter.
The fact that wc is the more difficult medium should carry no weight.The same goes for the conservative Transparent wc artist.The end product is what matters. To me there is nothing worse than a sappy,washed out watercolor that is done using strictly transparent watercolor of a worn-out subject. Difficulty does not matter.
Unfortunately the wc market is flooded with mediocre art. There are mediocre oil paintings also but for the reasons you mentioned above
such as a retirment hobby and asscessabilty of the medium there seem to be more out there.
Watercolor students are taught too many rules which I think blocks creativity.
We refer to Sargent's beautiful watercolors but let's face it hasn't been another Sargent in 100 years and his fame came from his oils.
Comments from a watercolor artist at heart.

Hi Jinnie, thank you for your comment. Jinnie is the friend I mentioned in my blog. I agree, there is way too much bad art, in general, out there. The worst part is - someone is buying it, making the creator of the work think it is good. I feel, mildly, the same about impressionist oils; that has been 'waaay' overdone. So much so, that they are no longer being bought.
As for the rules, I think they have to be taught before they can be broken. I don't think enough design rules are being taught. The watercolor rules aren't written in stone and don't have to be followed. Unfortunately, many of the people making watercolor paintings are hobby painters and don't have the ability to break the rules.
See you tomorrow. Lol

Hello Judy; What a great informative and fun article to read, You covered a lot of ground. If I may mention another artist; Winslow Homer. Of course he also painted in watercolor first and used his paintings as models for larger oils he intended to paint, all along. His oils are great masterpieces. I have always loved his watercolors more. I know a lot of people feel that way, but if you asked 100 people at random, I am sure more would say just in general that oils are the best and oldest, never mind the 40,000 years of watercoloring. Watercolors have jewels of color a fresher less planned look and use layering and overlapping. Those are the reason I love watercolor. There are a lot of great oil paintings for sure, but they attract people who really appreciate size and the tedious minute details, Often overworked these people do not mind it. Watercolors should have the respect that they so well deserve. Both are done by great artists, Both are done utilizing talents for good subject matter, composition, color balance, mixing colors. and then the differences, watercolors: bright transparent, fresh, uses matting and glass, and oils, Sometimes huge, takes longer uses big frames and no glass. Judy, I guess your article has awakened feelings and opinions I have had for years. Watercolor is my Watercolor is my favorite medium also. And thanks again for writing the article. Sincerely. Barry Clompus


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post