"Paintings With Personality"

Are You a Serious Fine Artist? What is your label?

Please meet 'Blue Wildebeest.' I saw this creature at Safari Park in Southern Virginia. I took lots of photos of amazing animals when Honey and I were there. In the meantime, the animals were slobbering all over my car. First thing I did when we left was get my car washed! Back to my painting, it is on a full sheet of Arches 140lb watercolor paper, 22x30, using transparent and opaque watercolor. I was in love with the shadows falling across the animal.

One of our daughters and I went to an ‘Off Off Broadway’ play Friday night. We knew the ten year old girl who was in the play and wanted to see her performance. She was truly amazing, and we had a great time. ‘Off Off’ and ‘Off Broadway’ plays are more fun than the extravagant Broadway productions, they are easy going as well as up close and personal. The actors are experienced and many have played on Broadway at one time or other. In other words, you don’t have to go to Broadway to see a good show and enjoy an evening out.

The same is true with art. Visual artists, whatever form or art they follow, are often referred to as professional, amateur, or hobbyist. The labels have nothing to do with the quality of their art, and they won’t change the art produced. Amateurs are usually just as talented as professionals. Let’s take a look at the dictionary.com definition of what it means to be a hobbyist, an amateur or a professional.

Hobby: an activity or interest pursued for pleasure or relaxation and not as a main occupation.

These artists don’t work very often. When they do work, their art often emulates something from the last exhibition they saw, or from the latest workshop they took. They don’t work enough to have a style of their own.

Amateur: A person who engages in a study, sport, or other activity for pleasure rather than for financial benefit or professional reason. This definition lets the artist enjoy making art, take workshops, and work when they want because their art doesn’t have to pay the bills.

Amateurs don’t have to submit to anyone’s demands, but can make their own choices about their art. They are free to experiment and try different things, enjoying the flexibility of creating what they want, when they want. They pay for this freedom by accepting that they will be limited in the places where you can exhibit their art, and won’t get as much money for their work when they sell.

Professional: Following an occupation as a means of livelihood or for gain. According to this definition you aren’t a professional artist unless you are making a living with your art. To make art your profession, you have to love making art enough to be willing to work a minimum of 12 hours a day.

Your art is your product. To make a living from it, you must begin your day early by checking your email and responding to clients, updating your social media, shipping art you have sold, adding work to sell to Ebay and Etsy, updating your website and then for 6-8 hours, creating more art to sell. As much time is spent on business as in creating art. There will also be taxes to pay, and if there is any time left over, you can work on the art that you want to create.

The above labels become especially complicated when ‘professional or amateur’ are used to describe skill rather than career choice. Since there must be labels, I suggest ‘serious artist’ as an appropriate substitute for amateur. This tells galleries and clients how you work, not how you earn a living.

To be an artist takes expendable time, money and energy. You give up all free time to work on learning and practicing your art, with little hope of being reimbursed. Only by working a lot and working hard will your art improve. There is nothing wrong with being a hobby artist, it is simply a choice. If you are a ‘hobbyist,’ and want to achieve ‘serious’ status, all you have to do is work more.

What are your thoughts on the subject?

Have a great week, Judy

www.judyballance.com

 

 

 

The Nicest Way to View Art

Comments

19 Responses to Are You a Serious Fine Artist? What is your label?

Judy, I love the term "Serious Artist"! In fact, it makes me feel I can take myself more seriously! I paint nearly every day, show and sell often and spend many hours on the business side of art, but to anoint myself with the title "professional" still seems quite presumptuous. Saying I'm a "serious" artist actually reminds me that I value what I do in a way that is different from "amateur". Not that there is anything wrong with being an amateur! Somehow taking on the "serious" label adds further incentive to prioritize my artwork. Thank you!!!

This is a very interesting topic! I was having this very discussion only a few days ago in a pop-up gallery I am currently running with some artist friends. The artist I was sitting with at the time happened to say, 'We are just amateurs.' I disagreed. If you take the term 'Professional' as referring to only the monetary factors, and a livelihood being earned purely from your artwork, then none of my group could be considered to be in that category. But we are all 'serious' artists and some almost earn a living from their artwork.

In my own view, 'serious' artist is a better term and I would never call myself an 'amateur' because though I don't sell enough to live off (yet!) I have taken part in international events, most recently having a painting selected for the 6th Beijing International Art Biennale (with work on show from 96 countries) and also being invited out there in September (expenses covered). I have also taken part, again by international selection, in a Mark Rothko Plein Air painting residency (2012) in Daugavpils, Latvia, and my paintings are now in the Mark Rothko Centre permanent collection, along with original Rothkos. I see myself as following a line of visual enquiry which makes my work almost abstract but with some light references to the world around me. I have never seen myself as 'amateur' because my ongoing ideas drive my artwork with great commitment, and I know many very serious artists who make more art than they sell but they are truly professional in their approach and commitment. I think that the defining factors are commitment and approach and quality. I used to earn a living from doing portraits and animal paintings, and painted any subject the customer wanted, but the paint took me in a different direction and I now back up my artwork with part-time work in another area so I can follow my explorations. I admire and respect all kinds of artwork and hate definitions though I'm aware that we live in a world where they are demanded! For this reason if people ask if I am amateur or professional, I tend to say professional, and keep away from the subject of sales - though I do sell, just not enough to call it a 'living.'

I think that only the work can speak about where an artist stands artistically, and that the term 'professional' sometimes does not contain where an artist is with regards to their own work. Many now famous artists never sold a thing or very little (Van Gogh) and we would not term them 'amateur.'

(PS. I really like your painting 'Blue Wildebeest.')

The definition of amateur changed sometime in the 2d half of the 19th century with the introduction of photography, according to "Snapshot: Painters and Photography." Before that an amateur was someone like Gustave Caillebotte, a very serious artist. With cheap cameras, an amateur became someone who snapped photos.

Hi Judy,

I love the term "serious artist", it fits many artists that work very hard but have not flipped the switch to complete professional.

I have heard from others that I am just an "amateur". Of course,
I always take it as a negative in that context.

I am a Serious Artist.

Thank you

Thank you for a very enlightening article! You have made me re-think the term 'Amateur', I actually find it quite appropriate to describe my efforts. But perhaps I will need to enhance it with 'serious Amateur', for those who find it a dismissive description. Hey you can't please everyone!

There's always semi-pro. And, yes, Serious Artist does cover the field.

I like your work very much.

Thank you for writing.

Lee

Great topic! I like your thoughts as a guideline, but I challenge the idea that a professional artist must work 12 hours a day and give up all else as an absolute. It kind of reminds me of Julia Cameron's The Artist's Way... where she insists that the only way to be a successful writer is a strict regimen every day of writing for a set amount of time at the same time... (I don't remember the specifics.. I ceremoniously got rid of the book) ARGH! I am a professional writer, and that mentality is anathema to me! Same with my art. I prefer to look at it this way: you have to be 100 percent dedicated to your work, and I do agree that a professional artist is someone who does it for a living. I think it best to leave it at that, because everyone's successful creative process is different. Thank you highlighting the labels... helpful!

Judy you got it right! Being a professional artist myself - I wake up and start marketing, emailing, taking photos for social media, checking my website analytics.... Ok the list goes on. This lifestyle requires talent, dedication, support and understanding from family, help from professionals be it photographers or accountants or lawyers, just like any other small business. I run this operation myself and yet I have so much passion for it to me it's not work - it's what I live for. Any artist thinking about an art career should be warned - you need a lot of energy.
Thank you - great articals for those who need to define what they do!
Merry Christmas

Hi Dorothy,
Wonderful to hear from you. I have gotten some interesting comments on this post. I didn't realize the topic was so controversial.

Hi Fiona,
Congratulations on your (not small) accomplishments, and thank you for liking my Wildebeest. I generally refer to myself as a serious artist and have a friend who advertises herself as a fine art painter.
Any way you look at it, we just keep painting!

Hello Ken,
Thank you for that information. I never knew that about photography. These days photography is considered an art form.

Thank you for your comment, Jeffrey. Amateur looked a lot better in the dictionary definition than the connotations we give to the word.
I have heard "just an amateur" too and hope none of us is "just" anything.

Judy, lol. Love your sense of humor. My attitude changed too when I read the definition.

Thank you, Lee. I really like your close focus work.

Patrice, Thank you for your comment. I like what you said about being professional. Most of our lives are so busy we can't spend 12 hours doing any one thing.

Hello Robin,
I'm hoping my husband will start doing my marketing as soon as he gets out of the office of treasurer for New Jersey Watercolor Society. He isn't an artist but is very good with numbers, so they made him an honorary member.
Merry Christmas to you as well. Happy New Year too.

A banker's perspective: The Internal Revenue Service treats income that you earn outside of a job as either business income or hobby income, depending on the financial circumstances surrounding the income. Read more : http://www.ehow.com/info_8052720_definition-hobbies-taxes.htmlhttp://www.ehow.com/info_8052720_definition-hobbies-taxes.html

Thank you very much, Kathy. Everyone, this is my daughter, Kathy. I'm very proud of her, can you tell?

Thanks for a very interesting article, Mrs. Ballance. I agree that the difference among the three labels is not in 'quality' but rather, intention or as you put it, choice. I have come across work by hobbyist which compared very favourably with work done by 'professionals'.

Yes, I agree with your suggestions of a blanket label, 'serious artist'. I do not think the amateur and the hobbyist are any less serious about what they do than the 'professionals'.

Peace!


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post