"Paintings With Personality"

Fraud, Deceit, Scams and other Nefarious Schemes Concerning Fine Art Giclee Prints

I have titled this painting Longhorns. What a surprise. I saw them at Safari Park in Southern Virginia. They were roaming free, no wires or bars, but absolutely free. And they were so beautiful.

Last week I  said giclees were reproductions, I need to correct that statement. Giclees aren’t always reproductions, they could be photographs, or digitally created on a computer. Most  giclees (but not all) are reproductions of original paintings and look identical to the originals.  A lot of art fraud occurs as a result of these amazing true to life prints.

Perhaps the most notable, in the fraud department, is the Park West Gallery. Park West is the gallery which sells art on cruise ships. They have had a series of lawsuits filed against them for selling prints, at inflated prices, claiming they were originals. The gallery has made as much as $300 million a year selling prints of famous paintings created by famous artists.

Ebay is highly corrupted with giclee prints whose sellers claim they are original, not only does the buyer get cheated, but artists lose out as well. The misrepresentation has made people cautious about buying online without first seeing what they are getting. That discretion eliminates a good sales venue for honest artists and print publishers.

Not all of the deceipt has been online; in 2008, Sheryl Luxenburg, a Vancouver, Canada artist, was awarded a gold medal by The American Watercolor Society, that included $4000 in cash.  Later it was learned that her painting wasn’t a painting at all, but a combination of two photographs she had gotten from stock photos. The award was taken away by AWS, because of the negative press, but not because Luxenburg was guilty. You can find more about this issue at … http://makingamark.blogspot.com/2008/09/art-competitions-and-copyright-aws-gold.html .

Dishonest publishers and artists, realizing that people prefer low numbers when they purchase prints will print in one size and if it proves to be a good seller, will print the same print in a different size, beginning all over with number 1. Or, they’ll name a series of 150 prints, then name it something else and print 150 more, and so on until thousands will have been printed.

Scarsity is value, not thousands of prints.

Others have listed their work as “Fair Art Trade Guild Approved.” That doesn’t mean their particular giclee reproduction print has been approved. It only means that giclees have been approved as art prints.

With all this happening, you might wonder why giclee prints aren’t against the law. The answer to that is that giclee prints have a valid place in the art market. The technology lets artists reach a larger audience with their work, and lets people who cannot otherwise afford art have some in their homes. However, to be an investment, giclees must be framed archivally and that is expensive. If you buy a giclee fine art reproduction, make sure you can have it professionally framed.

In order to be confident you are getting an original painting or a “true” giclee reproduction, you need to make sure a “Certificate of Authenticity” comes with it. For more on this, see – http://www.artbusiness.com/certaut.html

You should also learn how to identify a giclee print, you can look online to find various methods, but they are all a bit risky. Hiring a professional appraiser is probably the best way, but that is expensive. Here is a good site I found, but it only talks about canvas:  http://www.bjdecastro.com/art-blog/2005/08/how-to-tell-if-it-is-an-original-reproduction-or-print/. Please let my readers and me know if you find a way to identify a watercolor giclee.

Prints that have not been properly framed or have faded are worthless, no one wants them. An unlimited reproduction, is only good for decorating your walls, there is no investment value.

Please share any information you have, inquiring minds want to know.  Later, Judy

http://judyballance.com/

 

The Nicest Way to View Art

Comments

1 Response to Fraud, Deceit, Scams and other Nefarious Schemes Concerning Fine Art Giclee Prints

My works of art are NOT reproductions but begin as Original Digital Paintings conceived and executed directly on the computer specifically to be printed as Limited-Edition Fine Art Giclée Paintings. The fraud surrounding hand-signed, so-called limited edition reproduced giclée prints is infuriating. They are not works of art; they are simply pictures of paintings. I use all the artistic resources I have accumulated over the past 48 years to compose and execute every one of my digital paintings. Computer generated art is only as good as an artist's skill and knowledge of color theory, composition, life experiences and literary background. The computer is merely a tool just like a brush or a pencil albeit an incredibly sophisticated tool. To guarantee exclusivity, the high-resolution source files (specifically the .tif files) I use for printing are permanently deleted once the 75th painting in a series is printed while some of these charlatans go on printing hundreds or even thousands of so-called limited editions and keep right on signing them. To hide the flat, dot-matrix nature of a print, scammers may apply a gel coating or, in some cases, hand-paint over the print to simulate brushstrokes, selling them as "original paintings". The kind of texture I use in my painting technique is visual texture (or implied texture). It is the illusion of 3D surface quality on a 2D plane, created through artistic techniques like shading, color variation, and pattern, rather than physical touch. It adds depth, realism, and emotional connection to my paintings allowing me to simulate textures of an abstract nature and I make no bones about it! I'm up front about all my techniques and I make certain my patrons are fully aware of exactly what they are buying. This is a subject that has been simmering in my subconscious. One more thing that irks me no end are people who insist that computer paintings are invalid and not paintings at all. Thank you for providing me with a format to blow off some steam. Curtis R Doll Jr.


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post